Space Shuttle Controversy

March 15, 1972

Report Outline
Decision to Build a Space Shuttle
Growth and Decline of Space Program
Arguments Against Shuttle Project

Decision to Build a Space Shuttle

1972: Year of Decision for Future Space Flight

The fate of America's manned space flight program hangs in the balance in 1972. With only two more Apollo moon missions scheduled, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration finds itself without a new long-range mandate to send men into space. But Nasa believes it has the ideal successor to Apollo. The agency has proposed, and President Nixon has endorsed, construction of a reusable space vehicle, commonly called the space shuttle.

As its name suggests, the shuttle would be capable of ferrying men and equipment between earth and space. Its lifetime of up to 100 round trips would lower the cost of space flight substantially, supporters argue. Further savings, as well as increased operational flexibility, would come from the shuttle's passenger-cargo payload capacity of up to 65,000 pounds. The space shuttle, Nasa declares, is “the key element in our program for the 197A.” In giving the go-ahead for shuttle development, President Nixon predicted that the vehicle would become “the workhorse of our whole space effort.”

Despite all of its purported advantages, the shuttle has detractors as well as admirers. Some critics contend that the project will cost several times more than is currently estimated. It is asserted also that there is no present or foreseeable need for a vehicle that would have to make about one flight a week to justify its development costs. Still another line of criticism holds that the project amounts to a welfare program for the depressed aerospace industry and that money earmarked for the shuttle should be spent instead on such things as rapid transit and health care. All of the foregoing arguments, and others, are sure to be heard again before Congress decides whether to appropriate funds for shuttle development.

ISSUE TRACKER for Related Reports
Space Exploration
Jul. 23, 2021  Space Exploration
Feb. 21, 2020  The Mars Mission
Aug. 04, 2017  New Space Race
Jun. 20, 2014  Search for Life On New Planets
Feb. 24, 2012  Space Program
Aug. 16, 2011  Weapons in Space
Oct. 16, 2009  Human Spaceflight
May 23, 2003  NASA's Future
Jul. 23, 1999  New Challenges in Space
Apr. 25, 1997  Space Program's Future
Dec. 24, 1993  Space Program's Future
Mar. 29, 1991  Uncertain Future for Man in Space
Jul. 31, 1987  Space Race
Feb. 07, 1986  Space Decisions after Challenger
Feb. 18, 1983  American Options in Space
Nov. 10, 1978  Changing U.S. Space Policy
Jul. 04, 1975  Cooperation in Space
Mar. 15, 1972  Space Shuttle Controversy
Oct. 01, 1969  Mission to Mars: Benefits Vs. Costs
Nov. 13, 1968  Goals in Space
Jun. 29, 1966  Future of Space Exploration
May 08, 1963  Moon Race Controversy
Jun. 27, 1962  Peaceful Use of Outer Space
Nov. 01, 1961  Space Exploration
Dec. 09, 1959  National Space Policy
Feb. 19, 1958  Control of Outer Space
Space Sciences and Exploration