Presidential Appointments and the Senate

October 23, 1928

Report Outline
The Senate and Cabinet Appointments
Appointments to Federal Commissions
Legal Status of Recess Appointments
Senate Rules on Executive Sessions

A large number of recess appointments given by President Coolidge since the adjournment of the first session of the present Congress, including two cabinet appointments and appointments to five of. the most important federal commissions, will be before the Senate for consideration when the Seventieth Congress meets for its short session December 4, 1928. The two cabinet appointments are those of William F. Whiting to be Secretary of Commerce, succeeding Herbert Hoover, resigned, and Roy O. West to be Secretary of the Interior, succeeding Hubert Work, resigned. All recess appointees are at present performing the duties of the offices to which they have been appointed.

Senators from western states gave notice soon after the appointment of Mr. West in July to be Secretary of the Interior that this appointment would be vigorously contested, and it is not unlikely that controversies over the personnel of the major regulatory commissions - controversies which have broken out at every session during the last five years - will be renewed during the coming session. Few of the commission appointments made during recent years have escaped criticism. While most of the President's appointments to commissions have ultimately been confirmed, two important appointments - those of Cyrus E. Woods and John J. Esch to be members of the Interstate Commerce Commission - were rejected by the Senate.

The attempt to prevent Senate approval of the West appointment may lead to a contest between the Senate and the President similar to that which arose in 1925 when the nomination of Charles Beecher Warren to be Attorney General of the United States was rejected. Senate action in the coming session will probably be influenced to some extent by the fact that, even if not confirmed by the Senate, the President's appointees can nevertheless continue to hold their offices until the end of the session, March 3, 1929, when the present administration will come to an end.

ISSUE TRACKER for Related Reports
Executive Powers and the Presidency
Feb. 24, 2006  Presidential Power
Nov. 15, 2002  Presidential Power
Feb. 02, 2001  The Bush Presidency
Jun. 20, 1997  Line-Item Veto
Jun. 14, 1996  First Ladies
Oct. 21, 1988  Dangers in Presidential Transitions
Jun. 10, 1988  The Quandary of Being Vice President
Jan. 06, 1984  Presidential Advisory Commissions
Jul. 28, 1978  Presidential Popularity
Feb. 13, 1976  Evaluating Presidential Performance
Dec. 12, 1975  Presidential Protection
Jul. 11, 1973  Presidential Reorganization
Mar. 07, 1973  Presidential Accountability
Sep. 24, 1971  Presidential Diplomacy
Nov. 11, 1970  Vice Presidency
Oct. 02, 1968  Presidential Power
Mar. 14, 1966  War Powers of the President
Nov. 23, 1960  Transfer of Executive Power
Apr. 04, 1956  Vice Presidency
Oct. 15, 1952  Change of Presidents
Jun. 09, 1950  President and Mid-Term Elections
Oct. 20, 1948  Federal Patronage
Mar. 24, 1948  The South and the Presidency
Dec. 05, 1947  Military Leaders and the Presidency
Apr. 16, 1947  Veto Power of the President
Sep. 20, 1945  Succession to the Presidency
Sep. 12, 1940  The War Powers of the President
Feb. 11, 1938  Emergency Powers of the President
Jan. 06, 1938  The Power to Declare War
Dec. 28, 1937  Extension of the Veto Power
Dec. 28, 1936  Limitation of the President's Tenure
Mar. 12, 1935  The President and the Congress
Dec. 16, 1932  The Veto Power of the President
May 28, 1931  Presidential Commissions
Oct. 23, 1928  Presidential Appointments and the Senate
Mar. 21, 1928  Business Conditions in Presidential Years
Jan. 20, 1927  The Monroe Doctrine
Mar. 18, 1925  The President's Power of Appointment
Sep. 10, 1923  The President's Position on Patronage
Congress Actions
Judicial Appointments
Powers and History of the Presidency