The Future of the Direct Primary

September 11, 1926

Report Outline
Nominating Conventions and Direct Primaries
Objections to Direct Primary System
The Short Ballot and Preferential Voting
Pre-Primary Conventions

A leading argument against the direct primary, dating from its first appearance in the United States as a substitute for the convention system, is founded upon the encouragement it affords to the excessive use of money in political campaigns. By largely increasing the expense of nomination to important offices, it is argued, the primary system has operated to exclude worthy candidates of small financial resources and to bring about the selection of less desirable types, thus lowering the standard of ability throughout public life.

Point has recently been given to this line of argument by the Senate investigating committee's disclosure of the large amounts expended in the primary campaigns resulting in the nomination of Col. Frank L. Smith and Rep. William S. Vare as the Republican senatorial candidates in Illinois and Pennsylvania, Opponents of the primary system have been quick to seize this advantage, and to bring forth additional arguments, in a significant, if still unorganized, movement for a general repeal or modification of state primary laws by the 1926 legislatures.

Attack Upon the Primary System

An attack upon the state-wide primary system in Pennsylvania was launched by Senator David A. Reed, a supporter of Senator Pepper in the recent campaign, in a speech, June 12, before the Republican State Committee at Philadelphia, in which he recommended a return to the convention system of nomination. Harry A. Mackey, manager of the successful Vare campaign, testified before the Senate investigating committee four days later to his belief that the primary system should be abolished. Governor Pinchot, the third candidate in the primary, later attributed the movement for repeal of the primary to the “reactionaries” and expressed the opinion that “there is as little chance that such a civic crime will be perpetrated as there is that the freedom of Pennsylvania's press.will be put under restrictions and restraints.”

ISSUE TRACKER for Related Reports
Presidential Candidates and Campaigns
Jan. 15, 2021  The Biden Presidency Updated
Jan. 31, 2020  Presidential Primaries
Nov. 16, 2018  The Presidency
Jan. 06, 2017  Trump Presidency
Mar. 06, 2015  Presidential Power
Feb. 03, 2012  Presidential Election
Jan. 30, 2009  The Obama Presidency
Aug. 08, 2008  Political Conventions
Jul. 18, 2008  Race and Politics
Apr. 20, 2007  Electing the President
Dec. 30, 1988  Promises vs. Problems
Jul. 10, 1987  Presidential Nomination Process
Feb. 03, 1984  Choosing Presidential Nominees
Jun. 06, 1980  Choosing Presidential Candidates
Apr. 09, 1976  Presidential Campaign Coverage
Feb. 23, 1972  Political Conventions
May 27, 1964  Foreign Policy Issues in Election Campaigns
Sep. 21, 1960  Voting in 1960
Jan. 06, 1960  Presidential Primaries, 1960
Jan. 04, 1956  Campaign Smearing
Nov. 30, 1955  Presidential Possibilities, 1956
May 09, 1952  Open Conventions
Jan. 16, 1952  Presidential Primaries, 1952
Oct. 12, 1949  Modernization of the Presidential Election
Jan. 14, 1948  Presidential Primaries
May 01, 1944  Foreign Policy in National Elections
Jan. 01, 1944  Choice of Candidates for the Presidency
Apr. 08, 1940  Republican Candidates for the Presidency, 1940
Apr. 01, 1940  Democratic Candidates for the Presidency, 1940
Jun. 19, 1939  Selection of Nominees for the Presidency
Aug. 19, 1938  Nomination by Primary
Mar. 11, 1936  Voting in Presidential Elections
Feb. 18, 1936  Presidential Candidates, 1936
Mar. 03, 1932  Decline of the Presidential Primary
Aug. 25, 1931  Presidential Candidates, 1932
May 05, 1928  National Nominating Conventions
Sep. 03, 1927  Presidential Candidates—1928
Jun. 14, 1927  Patronage Influence in Nominating Conventions
Sep. 11, 1926  The Future of the Direct Primary
Jul. 02, 1924  Proposed Reforms of Presidential Nominating Methods
Jun. 04, 1924  The Machinery of the Political Conventions
Mar. 15, 1924  Presidential Candidates and the Issues
Sep. 05, 1923  The Passing of the Second Term
Campaigns and Elections
Campaigns and Elections