Do Pregnant Women Lose Legal Rights?

July 28, 1989

Report Outline
Special Focus


Should mothers be held criminally responsible for their “cocaine babies”? Should reluctant women be forced to undergo Caesarean sections? In short, do women who do not have abortions lose certain rights over their own bodies that they otherwise would have? If so, how much should their freedom be restricted? And when—throughout their pregnancies, or only at the end, when the fetus can survive outside the womb? The answers are not simple, the decisions have been controversial, and there are serious dangers involved for both sides in the reproductive-rights controversy.

Go to top


Judges have been grappling with wrenching legal issues involving children since the days of Solomon, but the past 15 years have brought an increasing number and variety of difficult questions involving parents and children, women and fetuses into American courtrooms. Now law, politics and science are combining to add to the pressure for greater judicial intervention in women's pregnancies, and it is happening at a time when society is deeply divided or uncertain about fundamental questions involving birth, motherhood and family.

The U.S. Supreme Court invited even more pressure with its July 3 ruling that gave states greater leeway to regulate abortion. The decision, Webster v. Reproductive Health Services, could lead to new laws to control when, where and how women can undergo an abortion. It also could pave the way for greater regulation of the pregnancies of women who do not have abortions.

ISSUE TRACKER for Related Reports
Women's Rights
Apr. 03, 2020  The Equal Rights Amendment
Apr. 17, 2015  Girls' Rights
Apr. 03, 2012  Women's Rights
Nov. 13, 2009  Women in the Military
May 2008  Women's Rights
Mar. 21, 2008  Women in Politics
Feb. 28, 1997  Feminism's Future
Oct. 13, 1989  Should Women Be Allowed into Combat?
Jul. 28, 1989  Do Pregnant Women Lose Legal Rights?
Sep. 17, 1982  Women and Politics
Dec. 15, 1978  Equal Rights Fight
Jun. 23, 1978  The Rights Revolution
Jun. 13, 1975  International Women's Year
Jul. 05, 1973  Women's Consciousness Raising
Oct. 11, 1972  Women Voters
Aug. 05, 1970  Status of Women
Feb. 20, 1956  Women in Politics
Jan. 24, 1951  Womanpower in Mobilization
Apr. 04, 1946  Equal Rights Amendment
May 31, 1927  The Woman's Vote in National Elections
Abortion, Contraception and Reproductive Issues
Drug Abuse
Women's Health Issues