Railway Labor Disputes Legislation

March 8, 1926

Report Outline
The Watson-Parker and Howell-Barkley Bills
Analysis of Watson-Parker Bill
Past Legislation for Adjustment of Disputes
Protection of the Public Interest

The Watson-Parker bill, recently passed by the House and now pending before the Senate, represents an abandonment of the principles laid down in the Transportation Act of 1920 for the settlement of railway labor disputes, and a return to the principles which governed the adjustment of such disputes prior to the war.

The machinery of the Transportation Act was based upon wartime experience in the adjustment of labor controversies while the railroads were in Government operation. It rested, in the last analysis, upon the principle of compulsory arbitration. While submission of unsettled disputes to the Railroad Labor Board was made compulsory, it soon appeared that the Board was without power to enforce its awards. This lack of any power of enforcement was the most important of all the factors contributing to the failure of the Railroad Labor Board experiment.

Principles of the Watson-Parker Bill

The Watson-Parker bill completely abandons the principle of compulsory arbitration, and provides for the settlement of disputes through (1) conferences between representatives of the parties directly involved, (2) meditation and conciliation by a Government agency, and (3) voluntary arbitration. The decision of the arbitral board upon a dispute voluntarily submitted to arbitration is binding upon the parties and is enforceable by judicial process, but there is no provision for compulsion in the absence of an agreement to arbitrate.

ISSUE TRACKER for Related Reports
Oct. 14, 2022  Passenger Rail
May 01, 2009  High-Speed Trains Updated
Oct. 18, 2002  Future of Amtrak
Apr. 16, 1993  High-Speed Rail
Mar. 10, 1978  Future of American Railroads
Mar. 07, 1975  Railroad Reorganization
Jun. 20, 1973  Railroad Nationalization
Nov. 17, 1961  Railroad Subsidies
Aug. 24, 1960  Railroad Mergers
Jan. 01, 1958  Condition of the Railroads
Jan. 31, 1951  Railway Safety
Oct. 04, 1944  Railroad Freight Rates
Jun. 12, 1939  The Government and the Railroads
Apr. 21, 1938  Government Ownership of the Railroads
Dec. 07, 1937  Railroad Rates and Revenues
Jul. 17, 1937  Advances in Railway Passenger Service
Sep. 27, 1934  Railroad Rates And Federal Regulation of Transportation
Jan. 11, 1933  Railroad Receiverships and Reorganizations
Aug. 26, 1932  The Railroads and the Depression
Oct. 13, 1931  Wages of Railroad Labor
Jul. 09, 1931  Railroad Freight Rates
Feb. 14, 1931  The Railroad Consolidation Controversy
Sep. 19, 1927  The Problem of Railroad Valuation
Mar. 30, 1927  Railroad Consolidation and Prospective Legislation
Mar. 26, 1927  Principles of Railroad Consolidation
Mar. 08, 1926  Railway Labor Disputes Legislation
May 04, 1925  The Baltimore and Ohio Cooperation Plan
Sep. 12, 1924  National Railroad Consolidation and the Van Sweringen Merger
Aug. 14, 1924  Automatic Train Control in Relation to Railroad Casualties
May 28, 1924  The Condition of American Railroads
Government Labor-Management Relations
Unions and Labor-Management Relations