The New Schism in the Church and the Immaculate Conception

December 21, 1923
Entire Report
  1. Several denominations of the Church in the United States have entered a controversy over the varying merits of certain tenets. Two broad divisions exist: the Fundamentalists who assert an unquestioning belief in the literal interpretation of the scriptures and who adhere strictly to established dogmas, and; the Modernists, who adopt a scientific view of ecclesiastical history and who insist upon a liberal interpretation of Scriptural statements.

  2. The struggle between the Fundamentalists and the Modernists is going on at present in the Protestant Episcopal and the Presbyterian Churches. There is a similar tendency in the Roman Catholic Church but owing to its superior methods of discipline no movement of this kind has been able to gather headway. The controversy in the protestant denominations has been recently brought into prominence by the action of the Protestant Episcopal bishops at Dallas on November 14 when they issued a Pastoral Letter defining the Fundamentalist attitude and emphasizing the Virgin Birth. At the last General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church five articles of faith were adopted, as follows. “It is the essential doctrine of the church that the Holy Spirit inspired the writers of the Bible to keep from error; that Jesus Christ was born of the Virgin Mary; that He offered himself as a sacrifice to atone for the sins of His followers; that He arose from the dead with the same body in which He suffered; and that He showed his divine power by working miracles.”

  3. The Fundamentalists of all churches are combining to drive out the liberal viewpoint whereas the liberals of the various denominations have never joined together. However, indications that the groups in the various denominations opposing the Fundamentalists are rapidly drifting together to present a united front appeared when officials of the Modern Churchmen's Union, an Episcopalian organization, said that they would gladly join with the liberals of other churches.

  4. It has been observed that a similarity exists in the views of the present day Modernists and those of the adherents of Martin Luther. Luther held that each man is one with God and needs no interpreter standing between him and the Holy Spirit. He rejected many of the fixed Catholic dogmas. The second generation of his followers are declared to have taken alarm at Luther's temerity, especially in view of the teachings of the Jesuits who became active in the restoration of the old faith, and to have crept back to the shelter of the dogmas. The new Modernist movement has been declared to be no more than a renaissance of the original liberal Lutheran doctrine.

ISSUE TRACKER for Related Reports
Oct. 28, 2022  Church and State
May 29, 2020  Christians in the Mideast
Sep. 28, 2018  Christianity in America
Jun. 23, 2017  Future of the Christian Right
Jun. 07, 2013  Future of the Catholic Church
Jan. 2011  Crisis in the Catholic Church
Sep. 21, 2007  Rise of Megachurches
Sep. 14, 2001  Evangelical Christians
Feb. 26, 1999  Future of the Papacy
Dec. 11, 1998  Searching for Jesus
Jul. 22, 1988  The Revival of Religion in America
Dec. 02, 1983  Christmas Customs and Origins
Jun. 10, 1983  Martin Luther After 500 Years
Aug. 08, 1975  Year of Religion
Jul. 26, 1972  Fundamentalist Revival
Jan. 04, 1967  Religion in Upheaval
Aug. 03, 1966  Religious Rivalries in South Viet Nam
Nov. 11, 1964  Church Tax Exemption
Aug. 05, 1964  Catholic Schools
Oct. 14, 1963  Churches and Social Action
Jun. 19, 1963  Vatican Policy in a Revolutionary World
Jan. 05, 1962  Rome and Christian Unity
Mar. 26, 1958  Church-Related Education
Dec. 18, 1957  Church Consolidation
Jun. 05, 1957  Evangelism in America
Jun. 23, 1955  Religious Boom
Aug. 13, 1952  Church Unity in America
Feb. 12, 1947  Relations with the Vatican
Dec. 21, 1923  The New Schism in the Church and the Immaculate Conception