Report Summary December 18, 2009
 Current Issue Cover Photo

Housing the Homeless
Is the solution more shelters or affordable housing?
By Peter Katel

The face of homelessness is changing in the United States. In the past, the homeless typically were single men and women who lived on the street or in shelters; many were mentally ill or drug addicts, or both. But today's homeless may well be a suburban couple with children who lost their home to foreclosure and are staying with relatives or living at a shelter. As the recession continues to ravage. . . .

Read the Full Report (Subscription Required)
Buy Report PDF PDF


The Issues


Pro/Con
Should homelessness be redefined by HUD to include more youths and families?

Pro Pro
Phillip Lovell
Vice President for Education, Housing, and Youth Policy, First Focus. Written for CQ Researcher, Dec. 15, 2009
Howard Husock
Vice president for policy research, Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, and author, America's Trillion-Dollar Housing Mistake: The Failure of American Housing Policy. Written for CQ Researcher, Dec. 15, 2009


Spotlight
Funding cuts may reduce number of beds in shelters.

Mark Raymond is worried. He says funding cuts will prevent his organization's huge 1,350-bed shelter in Washington — among America's largest — from adequately serving homeless men and women in the nation's capital.

“Lots of programs that were started last year and this year are not to be funded next year,” says Raymond, director of administrative offices at the Community for Creative Non-Violence.

In late September, Clarence Carter, director of the city's Department of Human Services, announced a $12 million cut in homeless-services funding for fiscal 2010. D.C. Council member Tommy Wells, D-Ward 6, contended the cut could be as large as $20 million.Footnote 1 Either way, homeless shelters say they will have to scramble to find enough beds for the lethally cold hypothermia season.

The current economy has forced more people onto the streets, including more families in which jobs have been lost and no savings exist. The slow housing market means an increasing number of electricians and construction workers are unemployed.Footnote 2 Half the homeless adults in Washington don't receive regular income, including Social Security and disability checks. The 20 percent who are employed have a median monthly income of $524.

According to a January 2009 survey, 6,228 homeless people live in shelters or transitional housing in the District, a 3 percent increase over 2008.Footnote 3 In July the total included 703 homeless families and more than 1,400 homeless children. Last year, homelessness among families across the nation rose 9 percent but 25 percent in the District.Footnote 4

The number of teenagers without a place to live is also rising. But so is awareness of their plight. Recently, rappers Flava Flav, once homeless himself, and Chuck D., of the band Public Enemy, shared a Thanksgiving meal with the young residents at the Sasha Bruce House in Washington, which features programs for children ages 11–17. Typically, youths are reunited with their families or transitioned into more permanent care. Counseling services are provided, particularly as children without families transition into adulthood.

The two entertainers encouraged the youngsters to stay in school. “It takes three times as much to get your education later as now, so do it now,” Chuck D told the teens crowded around him. Later, Public Enemy performed, and Flava Flav stressed the importance of volunteerism. “If you're successful and can't talk to younger people in need, you got a problem,” he said.

A homeless man settles in at a Metro station in Washington (AFP/Getty Images/Paul J. Richards)
A homeless man settles in at a Metro station in Washington, D.C., in May 2009. More than 6,000 homeless people live in shelters or transitional housing in the District. (AFP/Getty Images/Paul J. Richards)

During his term, former Mayor Anthony A. Williams called for an end to homelessness by 2014.Footnote 5 A major component of his “Homeless No More” plan, now being implemented by current Mayor Adrian M. Fenty, is providing housing and financial support to those most at risk of becoming homeless. In early December, the District distributed $7.5 million in federal stimulus money to house homeless families and help struggling families remain in their homes. The money, from federal Homeless Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing funds awarded to the District in July, will help 680–800 households.Footnote 6 Those who have been homeless the longest and those with the most severe disabilities will be housed first. Proponents of the plan say programs in Denver, San Francisco, and Portland, Ore., have proven that providing housing and counseling is more humane and cost-effective than putting people in shelters.

Martha Burt and Sam Hall — researchers at the Urban Institute, a Washington think tank — endorse Fenty's focus on permanent supportive housing, but they caution he needs to keep the momentum going if homelessness is to be ended in the next four years.Footnote 7 However, Michael Ferrell, executive director of the District of Columbia Coalition for the Homeless, says ending homelessness by 2014 is “very highly unlikely” and calls for a multipronged approach.

“The first prong has to be prevention strategies, and quite frankly, that's preferable to addressing the problem on the back end,” he says. Homeless individuals and families should be rehoused as soon as possible, he explains, but the long-term goal should be to provide enough rental assistance or subsidies for up to 12 months to prevent homelessness from occurring in the first place.

But Raymond cautions against shifting the focus away from shelters. “So many people need subsidized housing,” he says, “that there is a year-and-a-half, two-year waiting list. Shelters are absolutely still necessary.”

The shift towards permanent supportive housing instead of shelters, however, is a national trend. Philip F. Mangano, until recently executive director of the U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness, had focused on getting people out of shelters and into homes. “When you ask the consumer what they want, they don't simply say a bed, blanket and a bowl of soup,” he said. “They say they want a place to live. We have resources being provided to us at record levels. If you look at the numbers for chronic homelessness, we're winning.”Footnote 8

— Emily DeRuy

[1] Darryl Fears, “Officials Squabble, Service Providers Scramble; No Matter How You Do the Math, Advocates Say, Less Money Means More People on Streets,” The Washington Post, Oct. 6, 2009, p. B2.

Footnote:
1. Darryl Fears, “Officials Squabble, Service Providers Scramble; No Matter How You Do the Math, Advocates Say, Less Money Means More People on Streets,” The Washington Post, Oct. 6, 2009, p. B2.

[2] Mary Otto, “A Growing Desperation; Housing, Economic Slumps May Portend Rise in Ranks of Region's Homeless, Survey Shows,” The Washington Post, Jan. 25, 2008, p. B1.

Footnote:
2. Mary Otto, “A Growing Desperation; Housing, Economic Slumps May Portend Rise in Ranks of Region's Homeless, Survey Shows,” The Washington Post, Jan. 25, 2008, p. B1.

[3] “A Summary of the 2009 Point in Time Enumeration for the District of Columbia,” The Community Partnership for the Prevention of Homelessness, www.community-partnership.org/docs/TCP%20Fact%20Sheet%20Point%20in%20Time%202009.pdf.

Footnote:
3. “A Summary of the 2009 Point in Time Enumeration for the District of Columbia,” The Community Partnership for the Prevention of Homelessness, www.community-partnership.org/docs/TCP%20Fact%20Sheet%20Point%20in%20Time%202009.pdf.

[4] “In the News,” Washington Legal Clinic for the Homeless, www.legalclinic.org/about/inthenews.asp.

Footnote:
4. “In the News,” Washington Legal Clinic for the Homeless, www.legalclinic.org/about/inthenews.asp.

[5] Anthony A. Williams, “Homeless No More: A Strategy for Ending Homelessness in Washington, D.C. by 2014,” U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, www.hrsa.gov/homeless/statefiles/dcap.pdf.

Footnote:
5. Anthony A. Williams, “Homeless No More: A Strategy for Ending Homelessness in Washington, D.C. by 2014,” U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, www.hrsa.gov/homeless/statefiles/dcap.pdf.

[6] Darryl Fears, “District to Disburse $7.5M in Stimulus Money to Help Homeless,” The Washington Post, Nov. 30, 2009.

Footnote:
6. Darryl Fears, “District to Disburse $7.5M in Stimulus Money to Help Homeless,” The Washington Post, Nov. 30, 2009.

[7] Martha Burt and Sam Hall, “What It Will Take to End Homelessness in D.C.,” The Urban Institute, July 13, 2008, www.urban.org/publications/901185.html.

Footnote:
7. Martha Burt and Sam Hall, “What It Will Take to End Homelessness in D.C.,” The Urban Institute, July 13, 2008, www.urban.org/publications/901185.html.

[8] Derek Kravitz, “Homelessness Official Wins Praise with Focus on Permanent Housing; Detractors Cite Mangano's Frequent Travel, Including Trips Abroad,” The Washington Post, Dec. 30, 2008, p. A13.

Footnote:
8. Derek Kravitz, “Homelessness Official Wins Praise with Focus on Permanent Housing; Detractors Cite Mangano's Frequent Travel, Including Trips Abroad,” The Washington Post, Dec. 30, 2008, p. A13.


Document Citation
Katel, P. (2009, December 18). Housing the homeless. CQ Researcher, 19, 1053-1076. Retrieved from http://library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/
Document ID: cqresrre2009121800
Document URL: http://library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/cqresrre2009121800


Issue Tracker for Related Reports
Housing
Apr. 05, 2013  Homeless Students
Dec. 14, 2012  Future of Homeownership
Dec. 18, 2009  Housing the Homeless
Nov. 02, 2007  Mortgage CrisisUpdated
Feb. 09, 2001  Affordable Housing
Jan. 06, 1989  Affordable Housing: Is There Enough?
Oct. 30, 1981  Creative Home Financing
Nov. 07, 1980  Housing the Poor
Dec. 21, 1979  Rental Housing Shortage
Nov. 24, 1978  Housing Restoration and Displacement
Apr. 22, 1977  Housing Outlook
Sep. 26, 1973  Housing Credit Crunch
Aug. 06, 1969  Communal Living
Jul. 09, 1969  Private Housing Squeeze
Mar. 04, 1966  Housing for the Poor
Apr. 10, 1963  Changing Housing Climate
Sep. 26, 1956  Prefabricated Housing
Sep. 02, 1949  Cooperative Housing
May 14, 1947  Liquidation of Rent Controls
Dec. 17, 1946  National Housing Emergency, 1946-1947
Mar. 05, 1946  New Types of Housing
Oct. 08, 1941  Rent Control
Aug. 02, 1938  The Future of Home Ownership
Sep. 05, 1934  Building Costs and Home Renovation
Nov. 20, 1933  Federal Home Loans and Housing
Nov. 17, 1931  Housing and Home Ownership

Browse Related Topics
Homelessness