Report Summary June 2, 2006
 Current Issue Cover Photo

War on Drugs
Should nonviolent drug users be subject to arrest?
By Peter Katel

President Bush's anti-drug campaign has increasingly focused on a law-enforcement model that attacks the “supply side” of the illegal drug industry — traffickers, smugglers and users — rather than on helping users through prevention and treatment, the so-called demand side. He also would like more middle and high schools to conduct random drug tests, although few have signed. . . .

Read the Full Report (Subscription Required)
Buy Report PDF PDF


Pro/Con
Should schools randomly test students for drug use?

Pro Pro
Bertha K. Madras, Ph.D.
Deputy Director of Demand Reduction, Office of National Drug Control Policy. Written for CQ Researcher, May 2006
Ethan Nadelmann and Jennifer Kern
Executive Director, Research Associate, Drug Policy Alliance. Written for CQ Researcher, May 2006


Spotlight

As America's premiere adult playground, Nevada has always pushed the envelope on cultural mores. Modern legalized casino gambling was born there, and a 1971 law legalized brothels in most Nevada counties. Footnote 1 Now Nevada could become the first state to treat marijuana like alcohol — making it legal, but regulated and taxed.

In November state voters will decide whether adults in Nevada can legally possess up to one ounce of pot for their own pleasure. Only those over 21 would be allowed to buy pot, and the penalty for killing or injuring someone while driving under the influence of either alcohol or marijuana would be doubled to 40 years. Footnote 2

The Marijuana Policy Project (MPP) wrote the proposed law and organized the campaign to sell it to voters in a referendum. The nonprofit has been campaigning for 11 years to abolish criminal penalties for marijuana use — experience that led them to name the Nevada organization the Committee to Regulate and Control Marijuana. Drug-war critics have always been turned off by the word “legalization,” says Ethan Nadelmann, executive director of Drug Policy Alliance, which is not involved in the Nevada campaign.

In most states, the modern marijuana decriminalization movement has involved only exempting “medical marijuana” users from prosecution, as Nevada did in 2000. Footnote *

In addition, first and second offenses for possessing non-medical marijuana are only misdemeanors in Nevada and do not carry any jail time (although treatment may be required). Third offenses are also classified as misdemeanors but can bring a sentence of up to one year; any further offenses are felonies. Footnote 3

But Nevada's present arrangement still results in thousands of arrests each year, says Neal Levine, campaign manager for the legalization drive. “We had 86,000 people sign the petition to put this on the ballot,” he says. “We're saying, why not pull marijuana out of the criminal market . . . put it into a tightly regulated market where we can have sensible safeguards and have some control.”

Surveys show the measure faces an uphill fight. A poll commissioned by the Las Vegas Review-Journal showed opinion running 56-34 against, with only 10 percent of those surveyed undecided. In 2004, the MPP failed to get a similar measure on the ballot, when 2,000 petition signatures from newly registered voters were disqualified. Two years before that, marijuana legalization was on the ballot — but lost by a 61-39 margin. Campaigners blame the defeat largely on the fact that the measure would have allowed up to three ounces of pot — which voters apparently felt was too much. Footnote 4

Levine says his organization's polling shows opinion “roughly even.” But Nadelmann says it is “highly unusual” for an initiative to emerge victorious with less than 50 percent going in. He calls the Nevada campaign “premature.”

Stan Olsen, executive director for intergovernmental affairs of the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department, says, “People know what the drug culture has created in this country, and it's not a good thing. They know that the people pushing this are for one thing — getting loaded.” A former lieutenant, Olsen says the medical marijuana law has worked well, but he dismisses the argument that ending marijuana prohibition would free police to pursue violent criminals. “You can say, 'Let's legalize burglary — it's nonviolent and happens when people aren't home.' ”

But Levine says most Nevadans feel that arresting people just for smoking or possessing small quantities of marijuana makes no sense. And Nevada “is a very pragmatic state.”

[1] Roger Dunstan, “History of Gambling in the United States,” chapter II in Gambling in California, January 1997, California State Library [online, book-length study], www.library.ca.gov/CRB/97/03/Chapt2.html; and “The ultimate sin tax: Nevada considers taxing hookers,” The Associated Press, 2/26/03, www.cnn.com/2003/US/West/02/26/brothel.tax.ap.

Footnote:
1. Roger Dunstan, “History of Gambling in the United States,” chapter II in Gambling in California, January 1997, California State Library [online, book-length study], www.library.ca.gov/CRB/97/03/Chapt2.html; and “The ultimate sin tax: Nevada considers taxing hookers,” The Associated Press, 2/26/03, www.cnn.com/2003/US/West/02/26/brothel.tax.ap.

[2] “Regulation of Marijuana Initiative,” www.regulatemarijuana.org/home/06init.

Footnote:
2. “Regulation of Marijuana Initiative,” www.regulatemarijuana.org/home/06init.

[3] ”State-by-State Laws,” National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws, updated 9/22/05, www.norml.org/index.cfm?wtm_view=&Group_ID=4550.

Footnote:
3. ”State-by-State Laws,” National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws, updated 9/22/05, www.norml.org/index.cfm?wtm_view=&Group_ID=4550.

[4] Ed Vogel, “Marijuana measure opposed,” Las Vegas Review-Journal, April 11, 2006, p. B1; Ed Vogel, “Marijuana hearing rejected,” Las Vegas Review-Journal, Sept. 29, 2004, p. B4.

Footnote:
4. Ed Vogel, “Marijuana measure opposed,” Las Vegas Review-Journal, April 11, 2006, p. B1; Ed Vogel, “Marijuana hearing rejected,” Las Vegas Review-Journal, Sept. 29, 2004, p. B4.


Document Citation
Katel, P. (2006, June 2). War on drugs. CQ Researcher, 16, 481-504. Retrieved from http://library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/
Document ID: cqresrre2006060200
Document URL: http://library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/cqresrre2006060200


Issue Tracker for Related Reports
Drug Abuse and Trafficking
Jun. 03, 2011  Teen Drug Use
Jun. 12, 2009  Legalizing MarijuanaUpdated
Dec. 12, 2008  Mexico's Drug War
Feb. 09, 2007  Combating Addiction
Jun. 02, 2006  War on Drugs
Jul. 15, 2005  Methamphetamine
Jul. 28, 2000  Drug-Policy Debate
Nov. 20, 1998  Drug Testing
Jan. 06, 1995  Treating Addiction
Mar. 19, 1993  War on Drugs
Feb. 23, 1990  Does the War on Drugs Need a New Strategy?
May 20, 1988  The Business of Illicit Drugs
Jan. 23, 1987  Experimental Drugs
Feb. 08, 1985  The Fight Against Drug Smuggling
Aug. 27, 1982  Cocaine: Drug of the Eighties
Jun. 11, 1982  Prescription-Drug Abuse
Jan. 23, 1976  Changing U.S. Drug Policy
Dec. 13, 1972  World Drug Traffic
May 27, 1970  Heroin Addiction
Jan. 27, 1965  Psychotoxic Drugs
Jul. 18, 1962  Narcotics Addiction: Punishment or Treatment
Sep. 05, 1956  Control of Drug Addiction
Mar. 28, 1951  Drug Addiction

Browse Related Topics
Crime and Law Enforcement
Drug Abuse