Report Summary September 2, 2005
 Current Issue Cover Photo

Labor Unions' Future
Can they survive in the age of globalization?
By Pamela M. Prah

The American labor movement suffered a major blow at its 50th-anniversary convention in Chicago in July. The beleaguered AFL-CIO split nearly in half as seven unions formed the rival Change to Win coalition. The seceding unions argued that the AFL-CIO, led by John Sweeney, had been spending too much time and money trying to get Democrats elected to national office and not enough time recruiting new. . . .

Read the Full Report (Subscription Required)
Buy Report PDF PDF


Pro/Con
Will the split in the AFL-CIO revive the labor movement?

Pro Pro
Robert Reich
Former Secretary of Labor, Professor of social and economic policy, Brandeis University. Written for the CQ Researcher, August 2005
Richard W. Hurd
Professor of Labor Studies, Cornell University. Written for the CQ Researcher, August 2005


Spotlight

Nicodemo “Little Nicky” Scarfo, Vincent “Chin” Gigante and Anthony “Gaspipe” Casso are just some of the mobsters who have been involved with organized labor.

Scarfo, serving a 69-year prison sentence for racketeering, extortion and murder, ran the Hotel and Restaurant Employees union in the late 1980s. Genovese crime boss Gigante — who had allegedly infiltrated the International Longshoreman's Association — was later convicted of racketeering. And Casso — former underboss of the Luchese crime family and now serving a life sentence after admitting to 36 murders — was accused in 2001 of taking money to influence several construction unions, including a local of the Laborers' International Union of North America. Footnote 1

Several major U.S. Senate investigations beginning in the 1950s have documented organized crime's involvement with unions. Live telecasts of 1950-51 hearings of a special Senate panel chaired by Sen. Estes Kefauver (D-Tenn.) were credited with increasing the public's awareness of organized crime and the breadth of its stranglehold on unions and their pension funds. In a book about his committee's work, Kefauver wrote, the Mafia “is no fairy tale” and is engaged in “almost every conceivable type of criminal violence, including murder . . . smuggling . . . kidnapping and labor racketeering.” Footnote 2

Another probe, conducted in 1957-58 by the Senate Select Committee on Improper Activities in the Labor or Management Field, found “systemic” racketeering in both the International Brotherhood of Teamsters and the Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees (HERE) union. Footnote 3 The federal government took over both unions in the late 1980s and early '90s — the most drastic step it could take — to weed out mob influence.

In 1959 Congress passed the Landrum-Griffin Act, which requires that unions file annual financial reports showing how union dues are spent. Congress then passed the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act of 1970 — the so-called RICO act — which allowed the Justice Department to go after unions with mob ties.

In 1986, the President's Commission on Organized Crime reported that the Laborers' International Union was dominated by organized crime. Footnote 4 In the early 1980s, former Gambino family boss Paul Castellano was overheard saying, “Our job is to run the unions,” according to the FBI, which had planted bugs in Castellano's house in 1983. Footnote 5 Castellano was shot and killed in front of a steakhouse on New York's East Side in 1985 on the orders of future Gambino crime boss John Gotti.

According to federal authorities, union and mob bosses often team up to demand kickbacks from union members in return for prime job assignments. Crime families also have been known to demand money from contractors in exchange for “labor peace.” And contractors on union projects sometimes must pay salaries for “ghost” employees — crime family members who either don't show up or show up but do not work.

Prosecutors say union corruption in New York City inflates the already high cost of building union projects in Manhattan by $200 million to $500 million a year, an amount prosecutors sardonically call the “mob tax.” Footnote 6

By 2004, the Labor Department's inspector general had 359 pending labor racketeering investigations, of which more than a third involved organized crime. Footnote 7 Internal affairs of the “big four” unions — Teamsters, HERE, Laborers' and International Longshoreman's Association — still make up a significant portion of the Labor Department's racketeering investigations, the department said.

Union pension funds are a tempting target for labor racketeers. Union officials with mob ties have been found diverting union pension funds for their own personal use or investing the money in mob-tied businesses. Money from the Teamsters pension fund, for example, reportedly financed 85 percent of the casino hotels that appeared on the Las Vegas Strip in the late 1970s. Footnote 8

Three major unions with longtime corruption problems are still trying to rid their unions of corruption:

International Brotherhood of Teamsters — To many observers, the Teamsters is the poster boy for mob-run unions. The federal government deems the union so corrupt that it took over the union in 1989 and continues to oversee its operation.

The legendary Jimmy Hoffa, president of the Teamsters from 1957-71, was convicted of attempted bribery of a grand juror in 1967 and sentenced to 15 years in prison. In 1971, however, President Richard M. Nixon commuted his sentence to time served on the condition he not participate in union activities for 10 years.

Hoffa disappeared in 1975, never to be found, after leaving for a lunch with men linked to the Mafia. His son, James P. Hoffa, a labor lawyer, is now president of the 1.3-million-member union. He took over as president in 1998 after federal investigators discovered that union funds were being diverted to support President Ron Carey's 1996 re-election. Carey never served jail time, but some of his associates did. Last year, former federal prosecutor Edwin Stier, whom the Teamsters hired to clean up the union, resigned, saying Hoffa — who has vowed to get rid of federal oversight of the Teamsters — was retreating from his anti-corruption pledges. Footnote 9

Former Teamsters union President James R. Hoffa testifies in 1957 before the Senate Rackets Committee. He disappeared in 1975, presumably killed by former Mafia associates. (Getty Images/Al Muto)
Former Teamsters union President James R. Hoffa testifies in 1957 before the Senate Rackets Committee. He disappeared in 1975, presumably killed by former Mafia associates. (Getty Images/Al Muto)

Laborers' International Union — The federal government also keeps close tabs on the 800,000-member Laborers' union, which represents construction, maintenance and food service workers, but the union isn't in trusteeship. In 1995, the Justice Department decided not to pursue formal criminal charges but retained the right to file a racketeering suit if the union didn't clean up its act. In 2000 the union reached an agreement with the Justice Department after promising to retain “anti-corruption” reforms through 2006. Footnote 10 The union has removed at least 226 corrupt officials, including 125 who were linked to organized crime. Footnote 11 President Arthur A Coia Jr., a fund raiser for the Democratic Party and a visitor to the White House during Clinton's presidency, pleaded guilty in 2000 to a felony tax-evasion charge and was banned for life from holding any positions of power within the union. However, he was allowed to collect his $250,000 salary as “general president emeritus.” Footnote 12 Terrence O'Sullivan, a top aide to Coia, took over as president in 2000.

HERE-UNITE — The 2004 merger of the hotel workers union and the Union of Needletrades, Industrial and Textile Employees created HERE-UNITE, which represents nearly 450,000 hotel, casino and garment workers. In the 1930s, organized crime was linked to HERE locals in New York City and in the 1970s to locals in Florida. Footnote 13 In 1991, the Justice Department took control of HERE's Local 54 in Atlantic City, N.J., which represented hotel and casino workers and reportedly had ties to organized crime figures in Philadelphia. Footnote 14 In 1995, the Justice Department asked the courts to take over the entire HERE union, maintaining that the union was run by organized crime. Footnote 15 It was the first time the government resorted to such drastic action since it took over the Teamsters in 1989. The federal government oversaw the union until 2000, when the Justice Department determined the organization had largely purged its ties with organized crime. Footnote 16

[1] George McEvoy, “Mob Influence Checked in Some Years Ago,” Palm Beach Post, Aug. 30, 1995, p 1A; Carl Horowitz, “Union Corruption in America: Still a Growth Industry,” National Institute for Labor Relations Research, p. 36; and U.S. Department of Labor press release: “Scalamandre Brothers Plead Guilty to Mob Payoffs in Exchange for Labor Peace,” Oct. 31, 2001.

Footnote:
1. George McEvoy, “Mob Influence Checked in Some Years Ago,” Palm Beach Post, Aug. 30, 1995, p 1A; Carl Horowitz, “Union Corruption in America: Still a Growth Industry,” National Institute for Labor Relations Research, p. 36; and U.S. Department of Labor press release: “Scalamandre Brothers Plead Guilty to Mob Payoffs in Exchange for Labor Peace,” Oct. 31, 2001.

[2] Estes Kefauver, Crime in America (1952).

Footnote:
2. Estes Kefauver, Crime in America (1952).

[3] FBI Investigative Programs, Organized Crime, available at www.fbi.gov/hq/cid/orgcrime/lcn/laborrack.htm.

Footnote:
3. FBI Investigative Programs, Organized Crime, available at www.fbi.gov/hq/cid/orgcrime/lcn/laborrack.htm.

[4] President's Commission on Organized Crime, Report to the President and the Attorney General, “The Edge: Organized Crime, Business and Labor Unions,” U.S. Government Printing Office, March 1986.

Footnote:
4. President's Commission on Organized Crime, Report to the President and the Attorney General, “The Edge: Organized Crime, Business and Labor Unions,” U.S. Government Printing Office, March 1986.

[5] FBI Investigative Programs, op. cit.

Footnote:
5. FBI Investigative Programs, op. cit.

[6] Steven Malanga, “How To Run the Mob Out of Gotham,” City Journal, winter 2001.

Footnote:
6. Steven Malanga, “How To Run the Mob Out of Gotham,” City Journal, winter 2001.

[7] Office of Inspector General, U.S. Department of Labor, “The Evolution of Organized Crime and Labor Racketeering Corruption,” November 2004.

Footnote:
7. Office of Inspector General, U.S. Department of Labor, “The Evolution of Organized Crime and Labor Racketeering Corruption,” November 2004.

[8] “Heroes of Law Enforcement: Peter Wacks, Retired FBI Special Agent,” Illinois Police & Sheriff's News, available at www.ipsn.org/wacks.htm, updated Aug. 9, 2005.

Footnote:
8. “Heroes of Law Enforcement: Peter Wacks, Retired FBI Special Agent,” Illinois Police & Sheriff's News, available at www.ipsn.org/wacks.htm, updated Aug. 9, 2005.

[9] Steven Greenhouse, “Citing Pullback, Antigraft Team Quits Teamsters,” The New York Times, April 30, 2004, p. A1.

Footnote:
9. Steven Greenhouse, “Citing Pullback, Antigraft Team Quits Teamsters,” The New York Times, April 30, 2004, p. A1.

[10] Press release, U.S. Department of Justice, “Justice Department Announces New Agreement Continuing Laborers Union Reforms Until 2006,” Jan. 20, 2000.

Footnote:
10. Press release, U.S. Department of Justice, “Justice Department Announces New Agreement Continuing Laborers Union Reforms Until 2006,” Jan. 20, 2000.

[11] Carl Horowitz, “Union Corruption in America: Still A Growth Industry,” National Institute for Labor Research, 2004, p. 17.

Footnote:
11. Carl Horowitz, “Union Corruption in America: Still A Growth Industry,” National Institute for Labor Research, 2004, p. 17.

[12] Mike Stanton, “Coia enters guilty plea to felony fraud charge,” The Providence [Rhode Island] Journal, Feb. 1, 2000, p. B1.

Footnote:
12. Mike Stanton, “Coia enters guilty plea to felony fraud charge,” The Providence [Rhode Island] Journal, Feb. 1, 2000, p. B1.

[13] McEvoy, op. cit.

Footnote:
13. McEvoy, op. cit.

[14] Press release, “Casino Workers' Union Officers to Step Down,” April 12, 1991, released by PR News Wire; Horowitz, op. cit.

Footnote:
14. Press release, “Casino Workers' Union Officers to Step Down,” April 12, 1991, released by PR News Wire; Horowitz, op. cit.

[15] McEvoy, op. cit.

Footnote:
15. McEvoy, op. cit.

[16] Steven Greenhouse, “U.S. Agrees to End Oversight of Hotel-Restaurant Union,” The New York Times, Dec. 3, 2000. Section 1, p. 47.

Footnote:
16. Steven Greenhouse, “U.S. Agrees to End Oversight of Hotel-Restaurant Union,” The New York Times, Dec. 3, 2000. Section 1, p. 47.


Document Citation
Prah, P. M. (2005, September 2). Labor unions' future. CQ Researcher, 15, 709-732. Retrieved from http://library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/
Document ID: cqresrre2005090200
Document URL: http://library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/cqresrre2005090200


Issue Tracker for Related Reports
Labor Unions
Sep. 02, 2005  Labor Unions' FutureUpdated
Jun. 28, 1996  Labor Movement's Future
Nov. 06, 1981  Labor Under Siege
Mar. 24, 1978  Labor's Southern Strategy
Aug. 20, 1976  Labor's Options
Oct. 27, 1971  Organized Labor After the Freeze
Oct. 19, 1966  Labor Strife and the Public Interest
Jan. 30, 1963  Strike Action and the Law
Sep. 20, 1961  Conflicts in Organized Labor
Aug. 04, 1960  Labor, Management, and the National Interest
Dec. 16, 1959  Future of Free Collective Bargaining
Nov. 04, 1959  Featherbedding and Union Work Rules
Feb. 18, 1959  Public Intervention in Labor Disputes
Jul. 09, 1958  Suits Against Labor Unions
Nov. 13, 1957  Right-To-Work Laws
Oct. 31, 1956  Union Organizing
May 01, 1954  State Powers in Labor Relations
Oct. 02, 1953  Toward Labor Unity
Apr. 11, 1953  Industry-Wide Bargaining and Industry-Wide Strikes
Sep. 03, 1952  Labor and Politics
Mar. 25, 1950  Labor Injunctions
Jan. 25, 1950  Trade Unions and Productivity
Sep. 26, 1949  Fact-Finding Boards in Labor Disputes
Mar. 05, 1949  Closed Shop
Dec. 01, 1948  Revision of the Taft-Hartley Act
Jan. 01, 1947  Labor Unions, the Public and the Law
Oct. 09, 1946  Revision of the Wagner Act
Sep. 25, 1946  Labor Productivity
May 29, 1946  Labor Organization in the South
Jan. 30, 1946  Compulsory Settlement of Labor Disputes
May 18, 1945  Labor Policy After the War
Mar. 29, 1945  Union Maintenance
Feb. 02, 1945  Labor Relations in Coal Mining
Oct. 12, 1944  No-Strike Pledge
Sep. 16, 1944  Political Action by Organized Labor
May 30, 1944  Unionization of Foremen
Apr. 01, 1944  Dismissal Pay
Apr. 29, 1943  Labor in Government
Apr. 09, 1943  Public Regulation of Trade Unions
Nov. 19, 1941  Labor Policies of the Roosevelt Administration
Oct. 23, 1941  Closed Shop Issue in Labor Relations
Mar. 29, 1941  Labor as Partner in Production
Feb. 12, 1941  Labor and the Defense Program
Feb. 23, 1940  Labor in Politics
Jan. 17, 1939  Settlement of Disputes Between Labor Unions
Jul. 01, 1938  Three Years of National Labor Relations Act
Nov. 12, 1937  State Regulation of Labor Relations
Jul. 10, 1937  Restrictions on the Right to Strike
Apr. 28, 1937  The Labor Market and the Unemployed
Mar. 26, 1937  Control of the Sit-Down Strike
Mar. 13, 1937  Collective Bargaining in the Soft-Coal Industry
Jan. 22, 1937  Responsibility of Labor Unions
Nov. 11, 1936  Industrial Unionism and the A.F. of L.
Jul. 30, 1936  Federal Intervention in Labor Disputes
Jul. 14, 1936  Labor Relations in the Steel Industry
Apr. 17, 1934  Company Unions and Collective Bargaining
Feb. 07, 1934  Settlement of Labor Disputes
Sep. 12, 1933  Trade Unionism Under the Recovery Program
Feb. 17, 1932  Wage Concessions by Trade Unions
Oct. 01, 1929  Status of the American Labor Movement
Jul. 20, 1929  Trade Unionism in the South
Aug. 31, 1928  Organized Labor in National Politics
Feb. 04, 1928  The Use of Injunctions in Labor Disputes
Sep. 09, 1927  Organized Labor and the Works Council Movement
Oct. 12, 1923  The A.F. of L. and the “New Radicalism”

Browse Related Topics
Outsourcing and Immigration
Unions and Labor-Management Relations