Strip Mining

November 14, 1973

Report Outline
Conflicit Between Energy and Ecology
Development of Surface Mining Industry
Prospects for Reclamation and Control
Special Focus

Conflicit Between Energy and Ecology

Focus on Coal in Wake of Arab Oil Embargo

Strip mining is at the heart of one of America's most nagging and difficult domestic dilemmas: how to balance urgent energy needs with vital environmental protection. Stripping, as this controversial method of surface mining is often called, has inflicted severe damage on the land in Appalachia and the Midwest, and is now moving into the Northern Great Plains and the Southwest. The nation is hungry for power, and coal—America's most abundant energy resource—can be extracted quickly, easily and cheaply by strip mining. As the Arab oil embargo puts a squeeze on U.S. supplies of heating fuel and gasoline, “King Coal” is being called upon to ease the imminent energy shortages. Coal is not likely to help much this winter, however, because of severe diesel fuel and railroad car shortages which will hamper mining and delivery operations.

Coal's preeminence among potential answers to the nation's energy crisis is based mainly on the fact that there is so much of it—3.2 trillion tons underground in the United States, or 90 per cent of all domestic fossil fuel resources, according to the Interior Department. Some 400 billion tons are considered readily recoverable with current technology. Yet coal today supplies less than 20 per cent of U.S. energy. Because of this enormous potential, coal—which only a decade ago had been written off in favor of cheap natural gas, plentiful foreign oil and promising nuclear power—has suddenly become the rising star of the U.S. energy picture.

Many citizens, however, are growing concerned that strip mining may destroy much of the country in order to save it. The coal industry contends that strip mining is the best way to supply the mineral—that stripping is more efficient, less costly and much safer than underground mining. Environmentalists counter that the nation's needs could be met by a return to deep mining. Indeed, the Bureau of Mines estimates that there are only 45 billion tons of “economically strippable” coal, while some 355 billion tons could be deep mined. Regardless of the arguments against strip mining, the energy crisis is sure to increase the pressure for more of it—at least in the near future. President Nixon, in asking the nation on Nov. 7 to save fuel and electricity, spoke of making efforts to turn more coal into oil and said “We can take heart in the fact that we in the United States have half of the world's known coal reserves.” He mentioned strip mining only to say “We must have the legal ability to set reasonable standards for the surface mining of coal….”

ISSUE TRACKER for Related Reports
Environmental Protection
Dec. 02, 2016  Arctic Development
Apr. 22, 2016  Managing Western Lands
Jul. 18, 2014  Regulating Toxic Chemicals
Sep. 20, 2013  Future of the Arctic
Jun. 14, 2013  Climate Change
Nov. 06, 2012  Vanishing Biodiversity
Nov. 02, 2012  Managing Wildfires
Nov. 04, 2011  Managing Public Lands
Aug. 26, 2011  Gulf Coast Restoration
Jul. 2010  Plastic Pollution
Feb. 2010  Climate Change
Jan. 09, 2009  Confronting Warming
Dec. 05, 2008  Reducing Your Carbon Footprint
Nov. 2008  Carbon Trading
Oct. 03, 2008  Protecting Wetlands
Feb. 29, 2008  Buying Green
Dec. 14, 2007  Future of Recycling
Nov. 30, 2007  Disappearing Species
Feb. 2007  Curbing Climate Change
Dec. 01, 2006  The New Environmentalism
Jan. 27, 2006  Climate Change
Oct. 25, 2002  Bush and the Environment
Oct. 05, 2001  Invasive Species
Nov. 05, 1999  Saving Open Spaces
Jun. 11, 1999  Saving the Rain Forests
May 21, 1999  Setting Environmental Priorities
Mar. 19, 1999  Partisan Politics
Oct. 16, 1998  National Forests
Jun. 19, 1998  Environmental Justice
Aug. 23, 1996  Cleaning Up Hazardous Wastes
Mar. 31, 1995  Environmental Movement at 25
Jun. 19, 1992  Lead Poisoning
May 15, 1992  Jobs Vs. Environment
Jan. 17, 1992  Oil Spills
Sep. 20, 1991  Saving the Forests
Apr. 26, 1991  Electromagnetic Fields: Are They Dangerous?
Sep. 08, 1989  Free Market Environmental Protection
Dec. 09, 1988  Setting Environmental Priorities
Jul. 29, 1988  Living with Hazardous Wastes
Dec. 20, 1985  Requiem for Rain Forests?
Aug. 17, 1984  Protecting the Wilderness
Jun. 15, 1984  Troubled Ocean Fisheries
Aug. 19, 1983  America's Disappearing Wetlands
Feb. 22, 1980  Noise Control
Nov. 16, 1979  Closing the Environmental Decade
Oct. 13, 1978  Toxic Substance Control
Feb. 27, 1976  Pollution Control: Costs and Benefits
Nov. 28, 1975  Forest Policy
May 30, 1975  Wilderness Preservation
Dec. 20, 1974  Environmental Policy
Nov. 14, 1973  Strip Mining
Dec. 01, 1971  Global Pollution
Jul. 21, 1971  Protection of the Countryside
Jan. 06, 1971  Pollution Technology
Jun. 19, 1968  Protection of the Environment
Oct. 30, 1963  Noise Suppression
BROWSE RELATED TOPICS:
Coal
Land Resources and Property Rights
Mining